Heya Monks, here we have another week well spent. We’ve decided to put our favorite book series against one another.
Luckyfrog
I’ll try to be gentle, since you’re made for children
British ones at that, so just a couple of bell ends
But it’s time I bring up a copper cloud to make your spell end
Just another red head to the grave, I’ll send.
I mean, I guess you’re proof that to write you don’t need creativity
Just another teenage angst story full of stupidity.
Just skim through the wiki page for anything “supernatural”
And shove it in your plot hole casserole.
You solve any problem with the wave of wand to have the right ward
But let me show you a magic system that is actually hard.
We gain specific abilities based on vials of metal
While you burn through logic before your tea kettle
I’ve got that Iron pull and strategies that make you think
Not just expelliarmus to solve problems with every blink
So just cause you’re a hairy wizard doesn’t mean you have any chance to win
Because we’ve got a Mistborn here, and her name is Vin.
The Brick
Welcome you lot, and thank you monsieur!
Guv, we’ll try to be gen-teel that’s sure.
Your talk of creation is hilarious,
But bruv, you gots to be delirious.
Go ahead, correct me if I’m wrong here
But Lord Ruler’s not a feat of wit my dear.
Sure Sanderson’s got allomancers’ cunning
But our lady Granger’s just plain stunning.
You mention angsty teens waving wands about
But don’t you realize after book 1 you go sout’?
Now dry those tears, cuz we aint done,
After this your boggart will be Rowling, son!
Now you mentioned Weasleys in your diss,
And we tried our hardest just to dismiss.
But hold up while they grab the sword —
Check that, Art’s laughing at your magic — Lord!
“Vials of metal, thugs, and lurchers?”
“Is this how they expect to get past the bludgers?”
You see what he did, where his words did aim?
Was to compare your world to a wizard’s game!
Now let’s discuss wands before we finish,
A wizard’s powers without it don’t diminish,
While your mancers have metallic needs,
Wizards wands merely focus their deeds.
And you know I thought I’d leave it there,
But my heart still has more diss to bear.
Your writer seems to be quite fair,
But J. gave the world permission to dare.
Luckyfrog
So your complaint with us is the naming process?
Serious Black would like a word in his office.
Oh wait, but he died because.. I guess plot?
Added so much to the story and not just a random sad spot.
So many options, yet with one flick he’s gone.
But hey, at least he had more character development than Ron.
Don’t even get me started on Dumbledoofus the fool
Will somebody please call OSHA on this school
Got trolls, Cerberus, traps, snakes, and misc.
No security with several kids at risk
Sanderson writes and still hasn’t reached his peak
Didn’t take 7 books for a game of hide and seek.
Your expected patronum takes all of the fear out of “danger”
At any point did we really think we’d lose Miss Granger?
No instead we had to deal with her Ron Com
And oh no! Who will we take to the prom?!
Forget there’s a “dark lord” who shall not be named
So easily prevented.. everyone here is to blame.
The Brick
I see you, I hear you, now sit down and learn,
Like our own dear Minerva, we about to get stern.
I sat there and listened, then you sat down your pen,
Honestly all I could think of is where was your Vin?
You Sanderson boys love to gloat of your tale,
But please remember: it’s show us, don’t tell.
Rowling paints vivid landscapes and pages of thrills,
And continues with each book to inject us with feels.
Sanderson starts with such lovely, wonderful premises,
But soon the world and the story fall as flat as his nemesis.
I’d say that I’d sooner lick the lead out of dry paint,
But knowing that man, he’d turn me into an Allo’ saint.
Rowling in contrast has lead billions to read,
And her characters now inspire some to take lead.
As Dumbledore’s Army transcends from page to real life
I can totes understand why your stress does grow rife.
See the thing that you miss with every attempt
Isn’t the magic for which you hold your contempt.
Her stories aren’t grand because of some shining patronus,
But rather stand out for what they show that’s within us.
